Jennifer Aniston thought she finally found peace…
But insiders say her fairy tale may be cracking — and fast. 
In what was supposed to be her most grounded relationship in years, the Friends star is reportedly panicking after dark whispers about boyfriend Jim Curtis’s past started surfacing — and it’s already leaving her second-guessing everything.
WHO IS JIM CURTIS REALLY?
Jennifer, 55, has been quietly dating Curtis — a hypnotherapist and motivational speaker — since this summer, after meeting through mutual friends. The couple was first spotted soaking up the sun on a yacht in Mallorca back in July, and Jen even gave fans a rare glimpse of their life together with a sweet Instagram post featuring Jim and her beloved rescue dogs. 
But now?
That blissful bubble may be bursting. 
According to RadarOnline, Jen is growing increasingly uneasy after learning about Jim’s past connections — particularly his former fling with Real Housewives of New York City alum Bethenny Frankel.
BETHENNY SPILLS THE TEA… AND JEN IS NOT OKAY
On a recent episode of her podcast, Bethenny casually dropped a bombshell: She once dated Curtis around a decade ago. Though she insists it “wasn’t serious” and even poked fun at his job, calling it something she never “took seriously,” the damage was already done.
“It rattled Jen,” a source dished. “She was floating in that early bubble of romance, and Bethenny’s revelation jolted her. It was a reminder that she’s not the only one who knows Jim intimately—and she doesn’t like that.”
What’s worse? Bethenny’s massive influence in the media has only amplified the scrutiny.
“It’s left Jen wondering,” the insider continued. “‘Who else might come forward?’ She’s asking herself: What don’t I know? What if there’s more?”
A ROMANCE BUILT ON SECRETS?
Jennifer has long craved a drama-free love life. After high-profile heartbreaks and tabloid-fueled relationships, insiders say she found Jim’s quiet nature and steady presence refreshing.
“No games. No chaos. Just kindness,” one source revealed. “That’s what drew her in.”
But now? Even that calm exterior is being questioned.
“She’s starting to realize how little of his past she truly understands,” the source said. “She’s not saying she doesn’t trust him… but she’s definitely feeling shaken.”
MORE SECRETS TO COME?
So far, Curtis has stayed silent. No public comments. No damage control.
But some insiders are whispering that Bethenny’s podcast may just be the beginning.
With Curtis’s rising profile as “Jennifer Aniston’s new man,” more people from his past could see this as their moment to speak out.
And for Jen — who’s always fiercely guarded her privacy — this public attention may be her worst nightmare.
“She didn’t sign up for this,” one insider admitted. “She thought Jim was her escape from Hollywood drama. But now, it’s coming for her again — through him.”
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
Is Jennifer overreacting? Or is her gut trying to protect her from another heartbreak?
Will she confront Jim about his past… or walk away before more secrets come out?
One thing’s for sure — this love story just got complicated.